National Catholic Reporter    
 
Go to Search The center for the Catholic conversation... shaping the lives of 21st century Catholics

Why I'm going to the SOA protest

 Print Friendly Version
  On the Road to Peace by John Dear S.J.    Tuesday, Nov. 7, 2006  
       Vol. 1, No. 13  

Each year around Nov. 16, nearly 20,000 people gather at Fort Benning, Ga., outside the gates of the notorious "School of Americas." The school has trained some 64,000 Central and South Americans, many of whom have gone on to commit murder and torture as members of Latin American death squads -- a sinister distinction that has earned the place the more infamous title, the "School of Assassins." The yearly protests are by now as rooted as the Georgia pines and have the Pentagon on the defensive. The Pentagon's first official response was a PR move. A name change came down. They now call the place "The Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation."

The name has changed, but nothing else. The place still trains the aristocracy's thugs to brutalize the campesinos. There soldiers enroll in such courses as Counterinsurgency, Psychological Warfare, Military Intelligence and Interrogation Tactics. There soldiers study how to target Latin American educators, union organizers, catechists, student leaders, human rights workers, priests and nuns.

    Please take our brief survey.  Click here.

We train Latin American soldiers how to arrest, torture and behead. They learn how to stealthily assassinate a solitary target and massacre dozens in a village. To learn the art of killing, the SOA is the place to go.

I've gone four times already and was arrested with thousands of others in 1998 and 1999. But why go again? What good comes of it? I'm going for several reasons.

"Every known terrorist training camp must be shut down," said George W. Bush. I'm going to demand just that. Let the SOA be the first one to close. Immoral, inhuman, illegal, demonic -- this terrorist school has no right to exist. It's part and parcel of the web of lies, murder and massacres that the U.S. inflicts in Iraq every day. The SOA brings no democracy to our sisters and brothers in Latin America. It brings only death. A truly democratic institution would ensure the well-being of every adult and child through only nonviolent methods. A school promoting democracy would teach nonviolence and proudly embrace the name "Institute of Nonviolent Cooperation."

I'm going because some months ago I visited Colombia, where I witnessed the sinister fruits of the SOA. There I met Jesuits who suffer under daily death threats because they publicly work for human rights. There I met hundreds of mountain villagers who survived the massacre of their villages -- and their loved ones. Their blood stains the hands of death squads, soldiers and paramilitaries -- trained by the U.S. at the SOA.

There I saw the Bush administration's commitment to steal Colombia's natural resources. Both the stealing and the cost in deaths bear lightly on his conscience. Over the last 20 years, some 200,000 Colombians have been killed. Thirty political assassinations a day take place -- an astounding figure that leaps from the statistics file into my heart. The lurking assassins were inspired by the Pentagon, funded by the Congress, and trained in Georgia.

I'm going to the SOA protest because it's one of the best organized and more hopeful events in the church and the country. And it's one of the best examples of active nonviolence in our history. Plus it is beautiful and urgent liturgy. Its founder, my friend Fr. Roy Bourgeois, and his team, took the movement directly to South America this year and convinced the governments of Venezuela, Argentina, Uruguay and Bolivia not to send their troops to Georgia. And pressure grows in Congress for legislation that will put the SOA out of business.

I'm going to the SOA protest because Jesus himself was a victim of arrest, imprisonment and torture. And he died at the hands of imperial death squads. As one trying to be his follower, I want to side with him as he sides with the victims of the U.S empire around the world -- from El Salvador to Colombia to Iraq.

And I go to the SOA protest because I'm haunted by Ignacio Ellacuria and the other Jesuit martyrs of El Salvador. I worked with them for several months in 1985, four years before they were assassinated. They sent me and a few other young U.S. Jesuits to work in harassed refugee camps. Death squads lurked about, and on the occasions they approached, I went out to greet them. There was a rationale behind the plan. Perhaps the conspicuous presence of a North American would avert violence.

And so when they appeared, I hauled my trembling bones to the gate, all the while U.S. aircraft crisscrossed the sky and unleashed bombs in the near distance. Through my fear, I managed to learn a thing or two about faith, hope and love. It was the suffering people, and most of all the steadfast Jesuits who taught me best.

Fr. Ellacuria, a renowned theologian, philosopher, and university president, said: "The purpose of UCA, (the Jesuit university in El Salvador) is to promote the reign of God. But we have learned that if you wanted to promote the reign of God, you have to stand up publicly, actively, against the anti-reign. You can no longer say you are for peace and justice unless you publicly, actively stand up against war and injustice. You can no longer claim to pursue the good, unless you are publicly, actively resisting systemic, institutionalized, structured evil."

His insight profoundly moved me. It sounded like a new morality for a new millennium. Turns out it's what Gandhi had taught decades earlier: "Non-cooperation with evil is as much a duty as cooperation with good."

And they held on to it come what may. On Nov. 16, 1989, in the middle of the night, 28 soldiers -- 19 of them trained at the SOA -- burst in upon the Jesuits, shot up their house and forced them outside. They laid them on the ground and shot them dead. Then they removed their brains. It was "to send a message," said Jon Sobrino, a Jesuit who survived by virtue of his being in Thailand. "It was to say to all of Latin America -- ‘This is what you get if you think about reality.' "

The Jesuits' steadfast spirit, fearless determination, and strong faith still inspire me. I think of them every day. And so I go to the SOA to carry on their great work, to think about reality, to name the destruction of the poor carried by our nation. I go gratefully on this anniversary of their murders. Come Nov. 17-19, it's the only place to be.

And I urge you. If you're anguished over our sisters and brothers in Latin America, and with America's pursuit of torture and death, then on Nov. 17 come. If you're concerned about murder and war upholding "our way of life" and enlivened by the Gospel's call to be peacemakers, join the protest.

Come and remember the martyrs. Campaign to close our national terrorist training camp. You'll be hastening the advent of a world without war or injustice. You'll learn anew what it means to follow Jesus. And you'll be greatly blessed.

See you there.

Editor's Note: Fr. Dear will speak Friday, Nov. 17, at 7 p.m. at the Pax Christi gathering during the SOA weekend. His topic will be "Colombia."

  Archives    Signup for Weekly E-mail  

John Dear is a nationally known peacemaker, Jesuit priest and author, most recently, of You Will Be My Witnesses. For more info, see: www.fatherjohndear.org. For info on the School of Americas, see: www.soawatch.org or order a copy of the book School of Assassins: Guns, Greed and Globalization by Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer, (Orbis, 2001).

I've been participating in

I've been participating in the vigils at the SOA since '98. It's a deeply spiritual, solemn procession to honor victims of the graduates of that "school". As each name and age is intoned from the stage, thousands of people raise their crosses or Stars of David and say, "Presente" as one voice. We've never heard or seen any kind of anger. In fact, everyone there recites the Pledge of Non-Violence together.

May I add, as one of the new "SOAW 16", my family and I are pro-life Catholics who believe that all the Life issues are intertwined. We can't allow people to be born and then not care what happens to them! We were glad to hear Fr. John Dear speak up about Colombia at the Pax Christi gathering. Thanks...

Not yet rated.

I was amazed to find out

I was amazed to find out that you can't fly from Maine to Atlanta for less than $1,000 at this late notice, so I won't be going to the protest, which I feel awful about. But I will certainly be there in spirit!

I just read on soawatch.org that one of the men who massacred the four priests, and who had attended the SOA, was arrested in L.A. on October 18th after he had crossed the border illegally. He had spent only 2 years under house arrest for the crime... I hope now he'll be made to regret coming here.

Not yet rated.

Dear Mollyj, I would like to

Dear Mollyj,
I would like to try to answer your question: "William I think it is hard to strike the balance you talk about above. When is the protest too violent, does too much harm to others? What do we need to do to be effective?"
Colman McCarthy is interviewed by Tom Fox in a pod-cast found on the main page of NCR coverage of the SOA Watch.
This interview is very good for keeping us alert to the risk of spending too much time on protest. He is not suggesting that "the protest is too violent" or "does too much harm to others". He does, however, at least hint at a better way to spend our limited energy.

Not yet rated.

William, I did listen to

William,
I did listen to Colman McCarthy's interview by Tom Fox.

He is obviously heartfelt about what he teaches. But if you teach peace, you eventually teach interventions for peace. Consciousness raising, certainly. Gandhi exemplified peaceful protest. I think McCarthy lives peace and I agree he found the SOA protest distasteful (has it become an end in itself instead of a means?) but he didn't really articulate that.

The protest has become visible, perhaps more commercial. I was listening to a Democracy Now! podcast where a torture survivor was interviewed. Her torturer(s) were SOA trained. Her interview coincided with the SOA protest. I really cannot think that hearing this woman talk about her torture as a clear output of SOA was a bad thing. She was a high school student at the time of her disappearance and torture. It puts a face on who gets impacted by the school.

I guess I wish McCarthy would have talked more about the intervention ofs Peace--clearly he through education was important--education of students. He thought activism in prisons was important. Though I can make my guesses, I cannot clearly see what he didn't like about the SOA protests.

Not yet rated.

Thanks, William, I'll check

Thanks, William, I'll check it out. I love NCR's podcasts.

Not yet rated.

How many of our prolife

How many of our prolife bishops do you suppose will be there?

Rated 4 by 2 users. see individual ratings

Why limit your question to

Why limit your question to bishops? How many of the so called pro life people who demonstrate at abortion clinics and who seek to make elections about a single issue will be there?

Rated 4 by one user. see individual ratings

The distinction between

The distinction between "resisting" and "avoiding" evil seems like a minor semantic point when peoples' brains are being removed... John Dear and many others who understand the Gospel as a whole have been arrested and have offered absolutely no resistance while being arrested. And he has been arrested more than 75 times... how many cheeks could one turn?!

When he speaks about resistance he uses the example of a Jewish woman who was in a gas chamber in Auschwitz taking apart the structure brick by brick, until she was caught doing so. Should she have just died quietly? If this is resistance to evil, then I believe it cannot possibly be wrong in any way, shape or form.

Not yet rated.

The government must spend a

The government must spend a lot of money subsidizing the SOA ... I wonder how much?? Does anyone have any idea???

Not yet rated.

$20 BILLION is reported to

$20 BILLION is reported to have 'gone missing' in Iraq subsequent to US forces 'overseeing' domestic administration of the country's day-to-day business and attempts to 'protect' and 'rebuild' infrastructure. Because this was Iraqi money, the attitude of the American chief staffer on the ground, as reported last week on NPR was "who cares!" (I heard him say this.)

This is only a fraction of the +$300 BILLION spent 'legally' on 'infrastructure re-building', however, to pay American firms, chiefly Halliburton. And this money is NOT WAR EXPENDITURE (i.e., ordinance, equipment, staffing, etc.)

Whatever the SOA subsidy, we are unlikely to know the real figures because of its status as a front operation. In comparing the waste and war-profiteering in Iraq I mean only to point out the terrible human suffering that is a consequence of the fruits of operations like SOA when they come to light as the tragedy of war occupation. These are slow-growing tumors whose only 'security' functions are to maintain status and privilege in a global arena.

The Rev. Dr. E. McCoy

"So I say to you, Ask, and it will be given you; search, and you will find; knock, and the door will be opened for you." (Luke 11:9)

Rated 4 by one user. see individual ratings

This is a good question and

This is a good question and not easy to answer.

I found this:

Congressional Vote to Cut Funding for SOA/WHINESEC
http://www.soaw.org/new/pressrelease.php?id=110

I gather this did not pass....

This link does the best job of breaking down "who pays" for the services of WHINESEC:
http://www.ciponline.org/facts/soa.htm

It would appear that the latest year for which their are numbers if 2004. It looks like there is a rough number of a budget of $9.7 million dollars with $6.5 million of that coming from "Army Operations and Maitenance Funds" and the remainder, $2.1 (+) coming from "security Assistance Funds", which seem to be umbrellaed under some Department of Defense funds.

Even though SOA/WHINESSEC has taken A LOT of guff and seems to be an issue, doesn't seem like their overall budget has been harmed. Their 1995 budget was $3.8 million.

The above web site makes this summary:
Operating budget:
The cost of keeping the WHINSEC's doors open is currently $7.5 million. According to an August 2002 WHINSEC document, $1.2 million comes from security assistance funds (mainly IMET, INC, and the Defense Department's Counter-Terror Fellowship Program) and Foreign Military Sales (FMS).[9] The document does not specify the origin of the remaining $4.4 million, though much is probably Defense Department operations and maintenance funding.

During the late 1990s, the School of the Americas' operating budget was approximately $4 million per year. In 1999, about $2.8 million paid for civilian employees' salaries and the facility's maintenance, while $1.2 million in security assistance funds and Foreign Military Sales paid for students' attendance in SOA courses. The school's overall budget, including military salaries, was about $10 million per year.[1]

Not yet rated.

I can't think of a more

I can't think of a more worthy protest anyone who cares about justice could possibly attend... I feel terrible now because I hadn't made plans to go and now I'd really be scrambling to get there.

This "school" is an abomination and it is unconscionable that it is supported by our government. Perhaps now with the new Congress it will finally be able to be shut down.

Please pray for the safety of John Dear and all the others who will be there doing the work of peace.

Rated 4 by one user. see individual ratings

I honor the spirit of

I honor the spirit of lovingkindness and compassion that Father John has for those who suffer and are killed by the violent hands of the SOA. May you continue to have the courage of the Christ Consciousness: to love the Good forever. And for the All.

Not yet rated.

John Dear equates Fr.

John Dear equates Fr. Ellacuria’s statement: “You can no longer claim to pursue the good, unless you are publicly, actively resisting systemic, institutionalized, structured evil."– with Gandhi’s statement: "Non-cooperation with evil is as much a duty as cooperation with good."
This is a mistake. “Actively resisting systemic, institutionalized, structured evil."– is not the same as: “Non-cooperation with evil”.
The former is likely to violate the Christian principle: “Resist not evil. Rather, overcome evil with good.” Gandhi’s statement, however, is always consistent with the Christian principle: “Avoid evil and do good”.
In other words, the peace movement should emphasize doing good while avoiding the evil, but not “actively resisting the evil”.

Rated 2 by 2 users. see individual ratings

William I think it is hard

William I think it is hard to strike the balance you talk about above. When is the protest too violent, does too much harm to others? What do we need to do to be effective?

When doing any kind of activisim, there is a temptation to be sucked up in to the anger. I think that is why prayer and meditation is such an intergral part of the protest.

However, there is no doubt that SOA Watch, which NCR is partnered with, has single handedly brought this issue to forefront and that may define effective protest.

Rated 3.75 by 4 users. see individual ratings

Your response deseverves

Your response deseverves better that a four, unless I mulitppy it by 2.5.

Not yet rated.

I am proud of John for his

I am proud of John for his commitment to his beliefs. If I had the time and the money and the courage, I would go there too. I hope that John is not treated the same way that Jesus was treated and I wish that this "school" will be shut down permanently.

I will be praying for John's and the thousands of others will be able to nonviolently close this institution of terrorism.

Peace!

Rated 3 by one user. see individual ratings

I've never been to a protest

I've never been to a protest at SOA. I pray that God protect you and give you strength. One year it looked as though I might be able to go and I asked my nephew who was then stationed at Benning if I chained myself to the front door would he keep his comrades from shooting me, He said yes. It's always good to be brave and strong, but it never hurts to have a family member on the other side.

Rated 4 by one user. see individual ratings

Thank you Fr Dear and others

Thank you Fr Dear and others for your ongoing witness to the way of Christ.

God Bless

Not yet rated.